Ticket Change Details
Not logged in
Overview

Artifact ID: ae5d901f0c2cbd8aacb4132fbe4da71974ef050edc7e32a822b37e6ecbefc2fe
Ticket: 65c9cd1534b6e722bbc221ba917d0865a66a50e6
TIP 562 changes broke the trunk
User & Date: dgp 2020-03-05 18:32:14
Changes

  1. icomment:
    
    With the trunk working again, it's less critically important, but I do have one
    reservation in hindsight about TIP 562, which I understood in simple terms as
    dropping support for channel type versions 1 through 4, but retaining support
    for version 5 channels.
    
    That's not really what the TIP did, though. Some existing version 5 channels
    define a closeProc and may expect it to be called, but after TIP 562, it will
    not be called any more.  We really created a version 6 of the channelType
    but failed to bump the number.  I think I'd be happier if we made that bump
    to TCL_CHANNEL_VERSION_6 as part of the post-vote implementation review.
    We would make version 6 available in 8.7, and allow only it to go forward to Tcl 9.
    
    That's what we're already really doing; this would just label it more accurately.
    
  2. login: "dgp"
  3. mimetype: "text/plain"